Warner McCary: the black prophet

In a previous post, I documented Early Black Mormons, and gave a brief history of some of them. Warner (Aka William) McCary is a little-known black Mormon from the early days of the church. He was ordained an Elder by Apostle Orson Hyde in October 1846 and was known as the “black prophet.” McCary claimed to be part-Indian, though historian Connell O’ Donovan said in my previous post that

Warner “William” McCary was NOT half-Native American, although he claimed to be Choctaw. His mother was an African American slave and his father was her white master, a carpenter born in Pennsylvania. McCary made up his Native American heritage and traveled around the country putting on shows as an “Indian,” claiming to be the lost son of Moshullah Tubbee, a great Choctaw chief. It was a scam to make money.

I found some more detailed information about William McCary from the book Saints, Slaves, and Blacks by Newell Bringhurst. Following the Mormon exodus from Nauvoo in 1847, the saints traveled to Winter Quarters, Nebraska to start their journey to the west. It is at this point in history that (from pages 84-86),

McCary had arrived in the Mormon Camp sometime during that bleak winter of 1846-1847. At first, Brigham Young and other Church leaders welcomed or at least accepted McCary into their midst. McCary, an accomplished musician, entertained the encamped Saints during the months of February and March 1847.2

However, by late March 1847, McCary fell from Mormon favor. Young and others were apparently upset with McCary for using his powers as a musician and ventriloquist to claim supernatural powers of transmigration, that is, the ability to assume the “identity” of certain Old and New Testament peoples. At a “meeting of the twelve and others” McCary exhibited “himself in Indian costume” and purported “to be Adam, the ancient of days.” He “claimed to have an odd rib which he had discovered in his wife.”3 Then McCary “Showed his body to the company to see if he had a rib gone.” At this same meeting, McCary also tried to pass himself off as the ancient Apostle Thomas. He did this by throwing his voice and announcing that “God spoke unto him and called him Thomas.”4 Young and other church leaders were not impressed. The expelled McCary from Winter Quarters, and Apostle Orson Hyde preached a sermon “against his doctrine.”5

Undaunted, McCary remained in or returned to the area around Winter Quarters and proceeded to set up his own rival Mormon group; drawing followers away from Brigham Young.6 According to a July 1847 account, the the “negro prophet” exerted his influence by working “with a rod, like those of old.”7 By the fall of 1847, McCary’s religious practices took a new turn when the black Indian taught his own form of plural marriage of polygamy.8 McCary’s ritual involved a number of women,

sealed to him in his way which was as follows, he had a house in which this ordinance was preformed his wife…was in the room at the time of the performance no others was admitted the form of sealing was for the women to go to bed with him in the daytime as I am informed 3 diforant times by which they seald to the fullist extent.

These activities angered Brigham Young and his followers, particularly the relatives of McCary’s female disciples. One irate Mormon threatened “to shoot” McCary for trying “to kiss his girls.” But McCary, aware of the ruckus caused by the disclosure of his unorthodox practices, “made his way to Missouri on a fast trot.”9

The storm caused by William McCary, however had consequences far beyond the black Indian and his small following. In the wake of McCary’s activities at least two Mormon leaders were willing to affirm that blacks could not hold the priesthood. The earliest-known statement came from Apostle Parley P. Pratt in the spring of 1847. Pratt maintained the “McCary had ‘got the blood of Ham in him which linege [sic] was cursed as regards [to] the priesthood.'”10  Brigham Young alluded to this same position during the fall of 1847 when he suggested that blacks in general were ineligible to participate in certain sacred temple ordinances.11

It might be tempting to trace the priesthood ban to this particular episode. Certainly it played a part, but Bringhurst argues on page 86,

black priesthood denial did not emerge simply as the result of William McCary’s bizarre activities. A number of factors, complex and interrelated, caused Mormon leaders to deny blacks the priesthood.

The rest of the book discusses these complex factors. I have to say this is an amazing book. What do you make of William McCary?


5 comments on “Warner McCary: the black prophet

  1. Another piece of Mormon history I appreciate learning. Hopefully his expulsion (the Church or just WQ?) was not a racial issue. The leaders were trying to keep the Church from imploding and McCary’s behavior would’nt have been welcomed no matter what his color.

    Any info on his joining other factions after his move to Missouri?

  2. Well, McCary wasn’t the only person expelled for unauthorized polygamy. John C. Bennett is one that comes to mind. So in that respect, there could be a claim that it wasn’t racial. However, it is impossible to ignore McCary’s race in this incident. A pretty strong case can be made that McCary’s attempt at polygamy and Enoch Lewis’ 1846 marriage to a white LDS woman, Mary Matilda Webster in Boston, and their having a mixed-race child in 1847, was a contributing factor to the Priesthood ban. There are other issues, to be sure, but these 2 events came at a critical time in the formulation of the ban.

    Your question about other factions was great! I found a footnote on page 100 that says,

    According to one account, McCary joined Lyman Wight, then on his way to Texas. Other sources claimed that McCary joined Charles B. Thompson, the leader of a minor Mormon schismatic sect based in Iowa. Another witness reported that McCary traveled “South to his own tribe.”

  3. […] sex-and-gender discussion, but it seems like instead of having a big blowout on the subject, we see a few intriguing discussions each […]

  4. What do you know about Elijah Able? He was a black missionary ordained by Joseph Smith.

  5. Yes I’ve blogged about Elijah Abel before–I’m a big fan. It’s too bad Mormons don’t recognize him more.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: